Nuestras Últimas Noticias

By Mik Bodnar - Business Development Senior Manager

Strategy consulting firms are facing notable shifts in workforce dynamics, shaped by evolving market demands and regional economic conditions. Recent analysis by Vencon Research highlights significant headcount trends across Germany, Japan, the UAE, the UK, and the USA, offering valuable insights for HR leaders faced with these realities.

Workforce Trends in Strategy Consulting

The consulting industry continues to grapple with tightening talent markets and rising compensation pressures. Entry-level positions have been disproportionately affected, reflecting cost containment strategies and evolving hiring priorities. At the same time, senior roles such as Principal-level positions remain in demand, suggesting a focus on leadership and specialized expertise.

Meanwhile, regional disparities have become more pronounced. While mature markets like Germany and the USA reported negligible changes in overall headcount, the UAE experienced exceptional growth, driven by strong demand for consulting services in the region.

These trends align with broader industry shifts. Hybrid work models, purpose-driven consulting, and demand for cross-functional expertise are reshaping workforce strategies in the sector. Effective talent management, including targeted upskilling and leadership development programs, has become critical for retaining top talent in an increasingly competitive market.

Findings from Vencon Research

Vencon Research's year-on-year analysis of strategy consulting firms reveals the following key trends:

1. Declines in Entry-Level Roles: Analyst positions experienced the largest reductions, with headcounts decreasing by over 10% in Japan, the UK, and the USA.
2. Growth in Senior Roles: Principals were the only group to show consistent headcount increases across all regions studied.
3. Regional Variations:

• Minimal Changes in Germany and the USA: Overall headcounts remained relatively stable.
• Decreases in Japan and the UK: These markets saw modest declines in total headcount.
• Exceptional Growth in the UAE: Headcount increased by nearly 20%, with associate roles surging over 40%.

Implications for HR Leaders in Strategy Consulting

Current workforce trends present both challenges and opportunities for HR and business leaders in strategy consulting. As firms reassess their approaches to talent management and compensation, several key questions emerge:

• Are our workforce trends aligned with market benchmarks, or should we adjust to remain competitive?
• How can we capitalize on opportunities to attract top talent amid rising attrition at competing firms?
• What measures can optimize compensation strategies, particularly for critical senior-level roles?

Addressing these issues demands a balanced strategy—maintaining workforce stability while remaining responsive to changing economic and market conditions. For example, reductions in entry-level positions may appear manageable in the short term but could weaken the talent pipeline over time. Conversely, growth at senior levels underscores the importance of retaining and fairly compensating leadership talent while controlling costs.

Making informed decisions starts with access to accurate, market-specific data. Vencon Research provides targeted solutions to help firms act decisively. Our compensation benchmarking services deliver precise, actionable insights tailored to strategy consulting firms, enabling leaders to align pay structures with evolving market realities. By including detailed job matching as a core component, these services ensure roles are benchmarked with precision, providing a solid foundation for competitive and equitable compensation plans.

Beyond benchmarking, Vencon Research offers customized solutions to tackle unique challenges. Whether addressing talent shortages in established markets, identifying growth opportunities in high-demand regions like the UAE, or refining workforce strategies in response to economic shifts, our expertise equips firms with the tools to act with confidence.

To learn how Vencon Research can support your firm in meeting workforce and compensation challenges, visit venconresearch.com. With comprehensive insights and practical solutions, strategy consulting firms can position themselves not only to overcome today’s challenges but to strengthen their teams for long-term success.

‍

By Veronika von Strachwitz-Camara - Business Development

In compensation management, a thorough understanding of market trends is essential for businesses aiming to attract and retain talent. This understanding is often gained from salary survey reports, which provide the crucial data points for crafting competitive compensation strategies.

Here, we explore the key indicators highlighted in Vencon Research salary surveys and how they inform decision-making across talent management scenarios.

Client Priorities: Focusing on Essentials

Clients consistently emphasize the usefulness of several key indicators from our salary survey report that help them get the insights they need to focus their compensation strategies.

Total Cash Compensation (TCC) Medians per Career Level:

This metric offers a comprehensive view of compensation, including base salaries and bonuses, serving as a fundamental benchmark.

Alongside Basic Salary and Bonus, Total Cash Compensation is presented in a separate tab, both for the current and previous year as well as in firm and incumbent weighted (link) forms. It is also viewable in the accompanying PDF presentation, as well as via the dashboard.

TCC offers the quickest overview of compensation in the market, while our percentile breakdown indicates the prevalence and level of variance from the median.

Basic Salary Medians per Career Level:

This view provides insights into salary structures across different career levels. Basic salary as a metric is essential for understanding baseline compensation.

Our reports present all data broken down into 5 career levels with 3 sub-levels each. These levels are carefully matched against participants own career structures to ensure like-for-like comparison.

Bonus Medians per Career Level:

Bonuses are integral to compensation packages, and understanding bonus medians helps assess reward structures and performance-based incentives. Bonuses are presented both in monetary value as well as in percentage of basic salary form.

Once again, we present not just the median but the full percentile scale, and allow for comparison with your own firm’s basic salary.

While the median serves as a reliable reference point for many firms, ambitious enterprises may explore higher percentiles for competitive insights.

Firm-weighted Salaries:

For smaller firms, firm-weighted salaries ensure balanced analyses reflective of diverse organizational landscapes.

The choice between firm-weighted and incumbent-weighted data depends on organizational size and preference. We recommend watching our three-minute video on the topic for a concise introduction to the difference in each approach.

Utilization of Data: Practical Applications

Beyond mere observation, clients utilize the data in our reports in various ways:

• Market Positioning Assessment: Well organised compensation data allows organizations to understand their competitive stance within the industry, including employee reactions to compensation changes, turnover trends, and job satisfaction levels.
• Global Teams Harmonizing Salary Ranges: Multinational corporations leverage survey data to align compensation frameworks across regions, empowering local HR teams to refine offerings.
• Strategic Recruitment: Key indicators inform the crafting of compelling compensation packages to attract both junior and senior talent, ensuring competitiveness in the talent market.
• Retention Strategies: By benchmarking against industry standards, organizations identify retention risks and implement targeted interventions to foster loyalty.
• Bonus Allocation: Insights from bonus medians and payout ratios guide organizations in strategically distributing bonuses based on performance and market benchmarks.

Tailoring Indicators to Needs

Different talent management scenarios require emphasis on specific indicators:

Recruiting Junior Levels:

Basic salary medians and bonus structures provide insights into entry-level compensation and growth potential.

Recruiting Senior Levels:

TCC medians and bonus potential are crucial for senior candidates assessing overall value propositions.

Retention Strategies:

Comparative analyses of salary increases aid in identifying retention risks and devising targeted retention strategies for each career level.

Bonus Allocation:

Analysis of bonus medians and payout ratios ensures fair and strategic bonus allocation aligned with performance metrics.

An Invaluable Tool for Compensation Management

Salary survey reports are invaluable tools for compensation management. By understanding key indicators and leveraging data-driven insights, businesses can develop competitive compensation strategies that attract, retain, and motivate top talent effectively.

Find out more about Vencon Research's Consultant Salary Survey here.

As a trusted HR partner for the consulting industry, Vencon Research is here to help you unlock the full potential of your team. Contact us to learn more about how we can support your HR needs and drive success for your business.

‍

By Yao Tang - Business Development

With labour shortages challenging growth, companies across all sectors in Japan face the dilemma of attracting and retaining top talent while upholding stringent standards. As many of Vencon Research’s local clients have shared with us, this is also a critical concern within the consulting industry.

Maintaining high standards in recruitment remains crucial. Lowering stringent entry requirements is still considered a last resort as businesses strive to secure top talents without compromising quality.

Current Challenges in Japan’s Talent Market:

With Asia's largest economy centered in Tokyo, Japan faces unique challenges in its job market. Major factors contributing to this include:

1. Discrepancy in Demand and Supply: Japan, housing Asia's largest and most diverse economy, centered in Tokyo, grapples with a talent shortage despite a low unemployment rate of 2.70%. Factors like the post-COVID economic resurgence, an aging population, and globalization contribute to a surge in demand for specialized talents, particularly in fields like consulting.

2. Lack of Talent Fluidity: The prevalent job-for-life mentality in Japan poses a significant hurdle to talent mobility. Extracting employees from entrenched positions is challenging due to deep-seated loyalty and risk aversion. Traditional Japanese firms, known for stability, discourage job changes, presenting recruitment challenges for employers.

3. High Cost of Talent Recruiting: Japan's agency culture expedites hiring but inflates recruitment expenses. Steep provisions, reaching up to 100% of a successful candidate's annual salary, pose financial challenges. Even tier-1 consulting firms face provisions of around 80%, contributing to inefficient recruitment processes.

Strategies to Navigate the Challenges:

As employers grapple with attracting and retaining top talent while upholding rigorous standards, strategic solutions come to the forefront, from investing in employer branding to streamlining recruitment processes:

1. Invest in Employer Branding: Highlight your company's unique culture, values, and growth opportunities through social media, employee testimonials, and industry accolades to attract top talent.

2. Develop Talent Pipelines: Forge partnerships with universities, professional organizations, and industry networks to identify potential candidates proactively, ensuring a steady stream of qualified candidates.

3. Offer Competitive Compensation and Benefits: Conduct market research to ensure competitive compensation packages. Consider additional perks, such as flexible work arrangements and wellness programs, to attract and retain talent.

4. Provide Training and Development: Invest in training programs to upskill employees and attract candidates valuing continuous learning. Offer opportunities for professional growth to increase satisfaction and retention.

5. Streamline Recruitment Processes: Optimize recruitment processes using technology, such as applicant tracking systems and video interviews, to reduce time-to-hire and enhance the candidate experience.

6. Cultivate a Positive Candidate Experience: Ensure a positive and professional experience throughout the recruitment process. Communicate transparently, provide timely feedback, and personalize the experience to make candidates feel valued.

One common factor uniting these initiatives is that they all underscore a commitment to securing and retaining top talent. Organizations implementing these will pave the way for a more robust and adaptable workforce, ensuring sustained success, even within a difficult landscape for talent acquisition.

Our focus at Vencon Research is on leveraging market data to devise competitive compensation solutions tailored to your needs. Our expertise lies in optimizing employer branding, streamlining recruitment processes, and offering strategic HR solutions. For further insights and to explore how our expertise can benefit your organization, please feel free to contact us.

‍

By Yao Tang - Business Development

In the dynamic world of consulting, cultivating a work environment that engages and motivates emerging professionals is not just a matter of good practice; it's a strategic imperative for sustained organizational success.

Beyond traditional onboarding practices, this article explores practical strategies that actively contribute to the fulfilment and long-term retention of your newest team members.

Understanding the diversity of our workforce is essential. Thus, customizing retention and motivation strategies to the unique needs and aspirations of our new graduates is a pivotal aspect of talent management that ensures a workforce committed to our shared goals. Happy and motivated professionals are more likely to stay with the organization, reducing turnover costs and contributing to the continuity of high-quality service delivery.

So, let's explore some practical tips specifically tailored to the consulting industry, taking into account the diverse needs of new graduates:

1. Emphasise Client Exposure: Let new grads know they'll work on various projects in different industries. It's a great motivator for those eager to get diverse experience.
2. Highlight Training: Talk up your training programs. New hires often appreciate structured learning to build their skills.
3. Connect Work to Clients: Emphasize how their work directly affects clients and organizations. Knowing they're making a real difference can be a big motivator.
4. Fast Learning Curve: Make sure new grads understand that consulting involves a quick learning curve. The chance to learn fast can be motivating for ambitious individuals.
5. Mentorship Programs: Pair new consultants with experienced professionals for guidance. It helps them navigate projects and provides career advice.
6. Build Client Relationships: Encourage strong client relationships. The satisfaction of project success and gaining client trust can be a big motivator.
7. Explore Different Roles: Let new grads try different roles to find what suits them best.
8. Work-Life Balance: Promote a healthy work-life balance. Consulting can be demanding, so support them in managing workload and stress.
9. Recognition and Rewards: Acknowledge outstanding performance with bonuses, promotions, and incentives.
10. Global Opportunities: Talk about chances for international assignments. Some may find working abroad motivating.
11. Continuous Learning: Stress the importance of staying updated on industry trends and technologies.
12. Client Feedback: Actively seek and share positive client feedback. Knowing their efforts are appreciated boosts motivation.
13. Team Collaboration: Highlight the importance of teamwork. Strong relationships with colleagues enhance job satisfaction.
14. Exit Options: Make sure new grads are aware of potential career paths within and outside consulting.

These practical strategies for engaging and motivating new graduates in the consulting sector underscore the importance of tailoring approaches to individual needs. By recognizing the diverse aspirations and preferences of emerging professionals, organizations can foster a work environment that not only attracts top talent but also retains it for the long haul.

Feel free to get in touch with Vencon Research to explore how our tailored advisory services, market intelligence, and ongoing support can enhance your firm's HR practices. Our team is here to collaborate with you and providing practical solutions that align with the unique needs of your workforce. Together, we can shape an environment where your HR strategies not only attract top talent but also cultivate a workplace culture that fosters long-term professional fulfilment.

‍

By Andy Klose - Associate Partner

In this series of articles, we would like to highlight an aspect of remuneration strategy that is often not given sufficient attention: The ratio of fixed and variable pay to total cash compensation (also known as "pay mix").

In today's fast-paced professional services landscape, the recruitment and retention of highly-skilled employees is paramount for success. However, not all companies can offer cash compensation packages that meet (or exceed) industry benchmarks, making the strategic design of pay structures increasingly important. This article explores the nuances of pay mix and its influence on a firm's capacity to both attract and retain top talent. Benchmarking percentiles are instrumental in guiding companies to align their compensation strategies with market realities. Through practical examples, we reveal how even minor alterations to remuneration structure can impact a company's competitiveness in the labour market.

In Part 1 of this series, we explained why the pay mix can be the defining differentiator, particularly from an employee’s perspective, when many of the other key elements of compensation across competing organisations are considered to be broadly similar. In Part 2 we discussed how pay mix affects the financials of firms, especially with regards to personnel costs. This Part 3 examines how pay mix should be adjusted in relation to the total cash compensation offered and how benchmarked market percentiles are the most effective indicator of competitive positioning. And, in the final Part 4 we will assess how pay mix may influence firms’ culture and performance.

Introduction

As people are the key asset for professional services firms in particular, hiring the right people, motivating them to perform at their best and retaining top talent are critical to success.

Companies have different operational models, service different market segments or clients resulting in different economic realities. As a consequence, not all companies will be able to offer total cash compensation packages which are “in line” with the market (i.e. around the market’s median) or above to attract the best talent in the market.

Therefore, particularly for companies forced to offer total cash compensation below the market’s median it is crucial to get the pay-mix right. Understanding and utilizing percentiles in the benchmarking process can provide valuable insights into compensation competitiveness.

Total cash compensation in relation to fixed and variable pay

The following example (Exhibit 1) illustrates this: Assuming the following five offers relate to comparable positions with comparable future prospects and development opportunities, etc., offered by three comparable companies with similar brand, status, market and growth prospects, etc.:

In the example above, both Firm 1 and Firm 4 offer the lowest total cash compensation (90). On the contrary, Firm 3 and Firm 5 offer the highest total cash compensation (100). Firm 2’s offer (95) is in between the other four offers.

The key difference though lies in the pay mix, particularly when comparing offers amounting to the same total cash compensation:

When comparing Firm 1 and Firm 4: Both firms offer the same total cash compensation (90), but Firm 1 offers a higher base salary (70) and a lower variable pay (20) than Firm 4, which offers a lower base salary (60) and a higher variable pay (30). When comparing these two offers, obviously Firm 1’s offer is more attractive, because less money is “at risk”.

The second comparison refers to Firm 3 and Firm 5. Both firms offer the same total cash compensation (100), but Firm 3 offers a lower base salary (60) and a higher variable pay (40) than Firm 5, which offers a higher base salary (70) and a lower variable pay (20). When comparing these two offers, obviously Firm 5’s offer is more attractive, because less money is “at risk”.

But generally, Firm 4s offer is the least attractive from all five offers, since it offers the lowest total cash compensation (90) and the lowest base salary (60). Assuming full transparency in the market, Firm 4 would be having the most problems in attracting talent.

In contrast, Firm 5s offer is the most attractive from all five offers, since it offers the highest total cash compensation (100) and the highest base salary (70). On the other hand, one could argue whether Firm 5 is overpaying by offering both, the highest total cash compensation and a very comfortable pay mix (with relatively little money “at risk”).

Pay mix as a means of offering competitive compensation

In the next example (Exhibit 2) we will focus on the first three offers of Firms 1 to 3, which are more in line what one would consider a rational approach for adjusting pay mix according to the size of total cash compensation offered:

We already highlighted the inverse correlation between size of total cash compensation and ratio of fixed to variable compensation components (aka pay mix): Simplified one can say, the higher total cash compensation, the higher is also the variable pay in relation to base salary and total cash compensation (or in other words: the “riskier” is the pay mix).

Pay mix and market percentiles of different pay elements

Assuming that these offers match the market’s pay range as follows: Firm 1’s total cash compensation (90) matches the lower quartile (25th percentile) of the market’s range, Firm 2’s offer (95) matches the median (50th percentile), and Firm 3’s offer (100) matches the upper quartile (75th percentile).

Considering the market positioning with regards to total cash compensation, ideally the positioning with regards to base salary should be the other way around: Firm 1 should target a higher market percentile (e.g. the 75th percentile) for base salary, Firm 2 could be targeting the median (50th percentile), and Firm 3 could offer a slightly more “aggressive” pay mix by targeting a lower percentile (e.g. the 25th percentile) for base salary.

From our experience in benchmarking hundreds of consulting and professional services firms we see, that these relationships and ratios are often overlooked when designing compensation models.

In summary, not all firms can offer market-competitive total cash compensation packages, making it critical to optimise their pay mix. We illustrated how companies with similar total cash compensation packages can differ in their attractiveness to candidates due to differences in their pay mix. Companies with a higher base salary and lower variable pay may be more attractive because they involve less financial risk for employees. The pay mix should be adjusted in relation to the total cash compensation offered, with higher compensation typically having a larger variable component (and vice versa). Ideally, companies should aim to align base pay with market percentiles to effectively attract and retain top talent.

We are at your disposal for further questions and suggestions regarding how you optimally design the pay mix (and/or remuneration systems) for your company.

Andy Klose is an Associate Partner at Vencon Research International and heads the firm’s consulting unit.

Vencon Research International is a leading provider of compensation benchmarking and research as well as of compensation and performance-related consulting services for professional service firms, especially for audit and tax, management consulting, and IT services firms. Vencon Research International provides services to a full range of clients in more than 75 countries worldwide and is proud to name more than 85% of the world’s major consulting and/or professional services firm its clients.

‍

PULSE SURVEY: ARGENTINA’S INFLATION AND HR PRACTICES AT CONSULTING FIRMS

Vencon Research’s 2022 Pulse Survey provides an insight into the effects of currency devaluation and inflationary pressures in Argentina. The survey results highlight the challenges faced by firms in Argentina in retaining their employees, and the measures they are taking to address the financial hardship faced by their employees.

1.  HIRING RAMPED UP IN RESPONSE TO INCREASING ATTRITION

 43% of firms reported experiencing an increase in voluntary attrition, which led to a higher rate of hiring to fill vacancies. While this is a concern, it’s reassuring to see that firms are proactively responding to this trend by increasing their hiring efforts.

‍

2.  RESPONSES FROM CONSULTING FIRMS

A significant majority of the respondents, 57%, reported that their employees are currently facing financial hardship due to inflation and/or currency devaluation. This is a worrying trend, but firms are taking steps to mitigate this issue with all of the firms surveyed adjusting compensation and/or extra payments in the last 12 months. An increase in base salary was the most popular measure taken to adjust compensation (29% of respondents). Additional payments(14%) and an increase in bonus/variable pay (14%) were also popular choices.

3.  DRIVERS OF COMPENSATION DECISIONS

The key influential factors “driving” compensation were identified as inflation (86%),cost of labour (29%), fluctuations in exchange rates (14%), and a rise in the cost of living expenses (14%).

It appears that a significant proportion of respondents (approximately 43%) were unable to make predictions regarding the anticipated situation in the next 12 months in Argentina. Despite this uncertainty, most firms are planning changes to their current compensation model in the coming 12 months, with all proposing to raise the base salary by over 20% and also boost the bonus by 20%.

‍

4.  REGULAR COMPENSATION REVIEWS ARE ESSENTIAL

Vencon Research’s 2022 “Pulse Survey” highlights the challenges that companies in Argentina face due to inflation and currency devaluation. While the results indicate a worrying trend of financial hardship among employees and an increase in voluntary attrition, the survey also highlights that firms are taking proactive measures to address these issues. With most firms planning to change their current compensation model in the coming 12 months, it’s clear that companies in Argentina need to regularly review and adjust their compensation offerings to mitigate the effects of inflation and currency devaluation.

‍

Should you have any further questions or would like to receive more detailed information on this topic, please reach out to us at info@venconresearch.com.

‍